Why are exclusive annuity leads more expensive than shared leads?

With a shared lead you compete against several agents for the same prospect, so contact and close rates drop. An exclusive lead goes to one agent only, which lifts contact and appointment rates — you pay more per lead but usually get a better return.

Are cheap annuity leads worth it?

Usually not. Very cheap leads are almost always shared, aged, or scraped — people who never asked to hear from an annuity agent. Because one FIA case pays a large commission, the leverage is in reaching and closing a few good prospects, not in buying the most leads for the least money.

Resources › ROI & cost

How Much Do Annuity Leads Cost?

Q: How much do annuity leads cost?

It depends on exclusivity. Shared annuity leads can be a few dollars each because they're sold to several agents. Exclusive fixed indexed annuity (FIA) leads typically run from about $15 to $50 or more each, because only one agent gets them. At BuyIASLeads, exclusive FIA lead packages are 100 for $2,000, 200 for $3,000, or 400 for $5,000 — each including a CRM and a year of nurture.

By Gregory Stevenson, producing FIA agent & author of Index Annuity Secrets · Updated October 2026

Short answer: shared annuity leads can be a few dollars each, while exclusive fixed indexed annuity (FIA) leads typically run from about $15 to $50+ each. The price gap is almost entirely about exclusivity and quality — and because a single annuity case pays a large commission, the more expensive exclusive lead usually returns more.

“How much do annuity leads cost?” is the first question most agents ask — and the honest answer is that price alone tells you very little. A $3 lead and a $40 lead are not the same product. Here's what actually drives the number, and what you should expect to pay in 2026.

Exclusive vs. shared: the price split

There are really two markets. Shared leads are sold to several agents at once, which is why they're cheap — but you're racing three to five other agents to the same phone. Exclusive leads go to one agent only, so they cost more per lead and convert far better. (We break this down in Exclusive vs. Shared Annuity Leads.)

Lead type	Typical cost	What you're really getting
Shared / aged	~$3–$15 each	Sold to several agents, or resold months later
Exclusive FIA	~$15–$50+ each	Yours alone, generated from a real opt-in
Exclusive + nurtured	Higher per lead	Introduced under your name and kept warm for you

What drives the price up or down

Exclusivity — one agent vs. many is the single biggest factor.
How the lead was generated — a real opt-in from someone who asked for indexed-annuity info is worth far more than scraped or aged data.
Nurture — a lead that's introduced under your name and followed up for months costs more than a raw name and number, and contacts at a higher rate.
Included tools — some programs bundle a CRM and delivery dashboard; others just hand you a spreadsheet.

What exclusive FIA leads cost at BuyIASLeads

Our pricing is published and package-based, so there's no per-lead haggling: 100 leads for $2,000, 200 for $3,000, or 400 for $5,000. Every lead is exclusive, generated from a real opt-in, introduced under your name, nurtured for a full year, and delivered into a CRM — with a 7-day replacement policy and no long contract. See the lead packages for the current details.

The number that actually matters

Cost per lead is the wrong thing to optimize. What matters is return: because one FIA case can pay several thousand dollars in commission, even a modest close rate on exclusive leads can return several times the package price. A 100-lead package at $2,000 that produces three cases at ~$3,000 each returns roughly 4× — which is why the “expensive” lead is often the cheaper one in the end. We walk through that math in Annuity Lead ROI: The Real Math.

See exact, published pricing

Exclusive FIA leads, introduced under your name and nurtured all year.

View lead packages →